theriverbeyond:

Ok so a part of the NtN epilogue that has always bugged me is how Alecto very specifically doesn’t know who Harrow is until she bites kisses her and tastes her blood

ALT

Which on its own wouldn’t necessarily mean much, except that Harrow is shown repeatedly to look almost exactly like Anastasia, and Alecto-in-her-aspect-as-Nona is shown to be very observant and aware of physical features. It’s not, like, a vision issue, after waking up Alecto immediately recognizes Pyrrha, and knows the general features of Harrow i.e. “black-eyed infant”. And in her aspect as Nona, she is keenly observant of physical features. She waxes poetic about all the little ways Honesty and Pyrrha’s red hair differs from Kiriona’s, and more than that, she immediately recognizes Kiriona’s corpse as the girl from her dream. So why doesn’t she recognize Harrow?

The other Lyctors recognize Harrow. The first thing Augustine says upon meeting her is: “Harrowhark the First—ninth saint, then, looking at you I can tell that’s appropriate”, and then in the same scene he calls her “Anastasia come again.” Mercymorn insults her (“You’re not as pretty as Anastasia”) but in that insult, she again emphasizes the physical similarity between Harrow and Anastasia. These statements are way more significant when you remember in this scene, Harrow has just woken up after travel through the River, and is still wearing a hospital gown. no black vestments, no Ninth Aesthetics, the only things really “Ninth” about her are her physical features.

And the first thing Alecto does after she realizes that Harrow is Anastasia’s blood is to apologize about Samael and reiterate her “vow”, which she specifically did not remember until after she remembered Anastasia.

ALT

So like. What does this mean? I cannot help but have a feeling that this relates to blood wards being broken by the blood of a relative, the Ninth House being the House of the Sewn Tongue, and the established fact that necromancy can fuck with memory and perception. I guess I had always assumed the original “sewn tongue” referred to Anastasia but like what if it referred to Alecto? And the established blood ward (the Tomb) could only be spoofed by a close relative (because John wouldn’t program it to let anyone but himself in), but theoretically what is stopping Anastasia from whipping up a theorem for a blood ward that simply requires any kind of direct genetic link? Why would Alecto have forgotten her vows, how does this relate to Samael, why was she swearing allegiance to Anastasia? If she was made to forget because that vow was a secret, who was it kept secret from (John, presumably), and why, and how will this impact Alecto’s motivations and actions in the next book? John seemed happy/relieved to see Alecto when she woke him up via sword-to-the-chest, but the Alecto he put to sleep (presumably) didn’t remember her vows to Anastasia, and the Alecto who stabs him does, and what could this mean? How does this all connect to Anastasia’s bones being nestled by the Rock on the inside of the tomb? Did Anastasia have a long term plan, or was she just hoping that the next time Alecto woke up that things would be Different? What could she possibly have hoped or assumed would have changed in that interim time? How does this connect to Alecto calling out for Anastasia right before John leads her into the Tomb? What HAPPENED between Anastasia and Alecto, and John, and Samael, and—(I am pulled off stage with a large hook)