i looove cytherea as a “nicest* person here was secretly the villain the whole time” reveal cause like. my problem with those is usually that they do a complete 180 in terms of personality and suddenly they’re a totally different person. they absolutely do not give a shit about these people they just spent so much time cohabitating with. they developed absolutely no empathy or compassion or remorse for the people who worked with them, trusted them, confided in them, tried to help them. it just never seemed realistic to me. i always end up wishing for more nuance. it feels like the authors tend to go for shock value over the actual substance of the character, unless they’re angling for a redemption arc.
cytherea, though.
cytherea is 10,000 years old and she’s been inches from death the entire time. these people’s lives mean something fundamentally different to her than they do to them. she kills jeannemary in a shocking and brutal and unnecessarily dramatic fashion, and then she offers gideon genuine compassion and comfort in the aftermath, and both of those things are true and authentic and both of them are motivated by the fact that lyctorhood is fucking terrible.
the way she was interacting with gideon was always a little weird and the fact that she does genuinely understand never goes away. she’s fucking old and weird and bored and in pain and she will gore a 14 year old in front of you and then she will hold your hand and give you well-meaning advice while you process the trauma. she will tell you how terrible it is that people are taking advantage of you, she will cradle you and pet your hair and tell you that you’re worth more than this, and then she will kill you like she killed all the rest of them. and it really is a shame that you don’t understand how that’s a mercy, too.
cytherea is scary because the kindness was never fake. and that’s why i love her.