2024-03-14 23:13:26 ¶ ● ⬈

katakaluptastrophy:

> I think what’s so interesting about Gideon as a narrator at the anniversary dinner is the fact that there’s clearly tensions that she’s just not picking up on because she’s only there to eat a dessert.

> But these people are all the immensely powerful leaders of the Houses and consider themselves to be in competition for literal godlike powers and the favour of the emperor.

> There’s so many little snippets that are potentially intriguing: why is Teacher trying to prime the Ninth to consider the Fifth a threat? Why are the Third and the Sixth “sizing each other up like prizefighters”? The Fifth absolutely knew what they were doing when they sat the teen heads of the opposing cults near each other.

> Through Gideon’s lens, Magnus’ speech is a little awkward jokey thing. But…the seneschal of the House that is known to be actively trying to absorb another House is saying it’s such a shame they’re all so remote from each other and what do they all have in common (and it’s so quiet you “could have heard a hair flutter to the floor”) - that had to feel a bit different to people who aren’t Gideon.

> Palamedes’ is dissecting the meaning of “Master Warden” and at one point compares it to a prison warden. ‘Dulcinea’ asking about whether Magnus and Abigail have children is perhaps less small talk and rather more pointedly political. Harrow’s apparently stilted conversation with Protesilaus is clearly her actually probing his limitations like he’s a bad Chat GPT-run chatbot.

> And then 'Dulcinea’ tells Gideon she liked the dinner because it was “useful”. In her typical “I never lied to you” way, Cyth wasn’t lying when she said Abigail had to die because of her hobby - Abigail Pent let loose on the Facility would have risked blowing Cyth’s cover sky high. But what does a Canaan House look like where after the dinner party, the Fifth go down to the facility, get a key, and survive to continue their 'the Houses are going to get along or else’ agenda? We’ve seen Fifth House soft power on a smaller scale in HTN: and it looks like inviting a teenager round for coffee, lulling her into a false sense of security with small talk, and then physically preventing her from leaving the room until she does what you want, while smiling the entire time. A series of little coffee chats could probably have led to a lot of cooperation in Canaan House, one way or another.

> Gideon jokes about Silas marrying Ianthe because of their similar colour pallete, but it does raise the fact that there seems to be some tension around the Third, its succession, and the *point* of Ianthe. Why is Silas openly saying Ianthe should have died at birth? Combined with Judith’s comments in the Cohort Intelligence Files about succession on the Third, it feels like there’s something else being said here that Gideon isn’t picking up on.

> And of course, Harrow wasn’t the only one desperate to become a Lyctor because her con was unsustainable. Presumably at some point Corona and Ianthe would be expected to marry, or at least take on more separate roles as Corona prepared to take over the throne and Ianthe was funneled off elsewhere. At some point, their package deal would have become unsustainable and Corona’s cover would have been blown. But much as Harrow wants to become a Lyctor so she can reveal the state of the Ninth without repercussions, Ianthe is probably in part motivated to become a Lyctor for the same reason. Because otherwise, what would Ianthe’s expected role have been? Amidst the suggestion of anxiety about the Idan succession, the dinner party also presents the fact that the reason Abigail and Magnus’ infertility isn’t a succession crisis for the ruling family of the Fifth is that Abigail’s younger brother dutifully married in his early 20s and had kids. We know there are branch families in Ida - Babs is from one. He may be a prince, but he’s not treated well, and you do get the sense that the stakes to stay in power in Ida are high.

> We don’t learn anything about the political situation in the Houses themselves during HTN or NTN, but in the wake of Canaan House, you have to suspect there are a number of tensions and concerns.