December 2013

By Robert J! Lake

It’s a pretty little synth tune. Bouncy, cheerful, and deceptively simple, at least for the first minute or so.

By Malcolm Brown

The dropped-pitch tubular bell intro (the same motif as Stellarum Salve) falls away in a hurry, in exchange for a heavy metal guitar jam. It meanders on from there, from high shrieking electro-thrash (1:20) to a calm, echoey bridge (2:00), to a gothic synth march, complete with chanting (2:30 on). The whole track foreshadows Eternity Served Cold a bit in tone.

Again, pedantic, but the pipes at the end of Reverie sound like a calliope

You’re quite right. You piqued my curiosity on the subject, so I did a little looking around. A pipe organ drives pressurized air through pipes to generate sound, while a calliope drives steam through oversized whistles to produce music. It’s a product of its time (late 19th to early 20th century), when steam power was abundant. Here’s a video of a calliope in action.

Potential Homestuck ending #231: the full Dorothy.

By Malcolm Brown

To dust off a terribly stale, overused cliché, this song is a tour de force. It’s one of my top five favorites throughout the entire catalog.

The quality of the music is superb. Piano and xylophone kick it off, and if you turn it up loud, you can hear the dull, thudding, secondary impact of the piano key (or possibly the hammer against the piano string). It’s akin to hearing the valves opening and closing on a clarinet or a saxophone during a particularly quiet solo. If that’s sampled, there’s no way to tell: it is perfection.

This is the first song in the Homestuck library that I went and sought out. I blasted through the first several acts in two weeks or less when I first read the comic. I watched the Flashes in order, but the sound attached to them didn’t really stick until this song popped up. This is the track that forced me to take pause, to recognize that there’s something special about the soundtrack for this web comic.

I looked it up on YouTube to listen to it, to replay parts of it. I found myself asking questions about it. What was that familiar melody in the middle, when Lord English was rainbow-fricasseeing all of the ghosts? (it was Revelawesome). Haven’t I heard that haunting piano tune at the end of the Flash before? (Penumbra Phantasm strikes again). 

It led me to look backwards at earlier music: there was more value here than I initially gave it credit. I listened to music, bought albums, and now here I am, writer of a snarky blog all about the music. All catalyzed by this one track.

By Toby “Radiation” Fox

I thought long and hard about how I would describe this song in brief: carnival thrash. That cool eastern-inspired hook just about makes the song, and it’s worth dealing with cackling fancy santas in all their glory. So goddamned catchy.

By Michael Guy Bowman

It’s a journey into an unbalanced yet determined mind, with wobbly melody driven forward by one of the more complex and interesting percussion lines on the album. Guess that Constant Confinement might have shaken a few marbles loose. Pink Floyd’s Brain Damage (from one of the greatest albums of all time) give off a similar unhinged vibe.

By Thomas “EidolonOrpheus” Ferkol

Where The Lordling is a crazy ball of energy (complete with sound effects contributed by Caliborn’s Casio, no doubt), this one’s more introspective. Graceful and flowing.

I love your blog A+

Thanks!

Wouldn’t be much of anything without the encouragement and participation of followers, and I’m very much appreciative of it! My ask box is always open, so feel free to comment.

On a distantly related note, things have gone simultaneously bananas and through the roof here since yesterday, so if you’re new here, welcome!

By Robert J! Lake

It’s got the same feeling of discovery and awe as Homestuck, only with a silo full of Pioneer sugar dumped onto it.

RATING: 10 / 13 – uuuuuuNGH. OH *MERRRCY*. THAT IS JuST. SOO. GRODY.

Cherubim is the most recent theme album (the most recent album of all, as a matter of fact) released officially. It’s built in pairs: the odd numbered songs (except for the last) are cheery, while the even numbered ones are dark and aggressive. Each pair is built from the same basic musical idea: each with its own take.

The album flirts with a saccharine, syrupy motif, but never really commits to it. The pizzicato strings, the cackling fancy santa… that’s just window dressing, just establishing the setting. No, the underlying theme is relentless, naive optimism against an unstoppable lust for power.

The production and editing is fantastic. Coming off of Alternia and Midnight Crew: Drawing Dead in my last few reviews, my appreciation for the intrinsic quality of this album is only greater than before. Everything’s been polished to a mirror sheen. All of the instrumentation is natural and, to my ear, may as well have been played by a live musician (except, of course, for the dedicated synth instruments).

Parts of the album nudge a little towards the experimental side, and it’s a tad soft in the middle, but overall this is a great themed compilation.

Click here for individual song reviews for Cherubim.

Sburb, a solo album composed by Tyler Dever and performed by Erik “Jit” Scheele, loading now.

Composed by Tyler Dever. Performed by Erik “Jit” Scheele.

Makes me think of daybreak, of new beginnings. Like a muted, simplified Ranz des Vaches.

I wonder if Namco High will have achievements…

Composed by Tyler Dever. Performed by Erik “Jit” Scheele.

The transition from The Prelude is ultra smooth, to the point that this may as well be a continuation. There’s no well-defined time, no well-defined measure: it feels professional yet improvised. It’s a style that’s consistent throughout the album.

Composed by Tyler Dever. Performed by Erik “Jit” Scheele.

Slow and deliberate on the bass side of the keys, and flighty on the treble side. The rather forceful rendition of Sburban Jungle near the end is a new, unique twist on the motif.

Composed by Tyler Dever. Performed by Erik “Jit” Scheele.

Such a simple intro, yet it evokes a melancholic mood as well as anything I’ve heard. My top track for the album.

Composed by Tyler Dever. Performed by Erik “Jit” Scheele.

Starts off with a chaotic glissando. I can’t decide whether it has the hallmarks and control of a professional, or if it’s better described as the ham-fisted smashings of a five-year-old. Either way, the melody that follows is austere and catchy.

Composed by Tyler Dever. Performed by Erik “Jit” Scheele.

I didn’t really dig Candles and Clockwork on Volume 5: it just felt forced with the synthy choir. But underneath all of that it has a pretty cool melody, and this track’s intro showcases it well. There’s a little more improvization in the second half, and it’s one of the tracks I come back to once in a while on this album.

What’s all this? That’s not music. It’s not music at all! Yet here it is on my pile of thrash here at BRO CENTRAL

It’s To Be Or Not To Be, written by Ryan North, best known for his starring role in an MSPA adventure. Also, he writes a paleontology blog or something.

I’ll post a review for it when I’m done. Might be a while, as it literally arrived yesterday. But I’ll get around to it.

RATING: 7 / 13 – A bit tender for my liking.

Genre varies wildly in the Homestuck catalog, from clean, simple chiptune tracks to epic, solid walls of sound. Sburb strips the music down to its barest.

There aren’t monster hooks or hits to be found. But that’s not what the album’s all about. Of all the compositions released in the library, this is the most cohesive, the one that works best as a single movement. It’s a professional, original recital. And it’s terribly intimate. No booming bass, no complex synth beat-box rhythms. Just one piano.

Usually when I rate music, I listen through once, mark off the songs I like in particular, then put it on continuous play for a while to better shape my opinion. I’ve listened to the album many times, and I find myself lost in the singular 30-minute arrangement each time. There’s no duds, no masterstrokes. Just a fine collection of piano music.

Click here for individual song reviews for Sburb.

BRO-NOTES: Pick the First Review of 2014!

Couple of quick things. I’m going to drop my queue down to once per day soon. No worries, though: with more than half the Homestuck music already reviewed, slackening the pace a little will give me a better shot at finishing all current music closer to when the Gigapause ends.

On to less boring news. I’ve got three full albums in the can: a PLAZMATAZ x2 COMBO, and a certain seasonally appropriate compilation. Reviews for these albums will be coming up next (and will probably run through December). After that, there’s about a dozen albums left.

So, I ask myself, what would be the wickedest, rudebrazenest way to choose the next review? MAD REQUESTS YO, like the thrashin’ pancake turner slam poets of old. I’ll pick my next album based on requests. Any album on this list is up for grabs (except for something I’ve already covered, which would be lame). So send me an ask. I’ll pick the winner based on some arbitrary metric I haven’t decided on yet.

We’ve got a PLAZMATAZ x2 COMBO coming up next, starting with Symphony Impossible to Play.

Arranged and composed by Clark “Plazmataz” Powell. Original ‘Crystalanthemums’ melody by Alexander Rosetti, 'Endless Climb,’ 'Doctor,’ 'Explore’ melodies by George Buzinkai, and 'Atomyk Ebonpyre’ by Toby “Radiation” Fox.

What a way to kick things off: a long crescendo from a deep strings section that echoes Endless Climb. That’s followed by a tease of a few more memorable tunes, all backed by those same strings and a forceful percussion beat.

That percussion line is best featured at the 4:25 mark, where the toms really take over (Plazmataz must have brought Ron Bushy in as a studio musician for that one).

Arranged by Clark “Plazmataz” Powell. Original “Sarabande” by Erik “Jit” Scheele.

The original version of Sarabande is one of my all-time favorites (my opinion of it has only improved over time). Some remixes change a song completely, or overpower it with counter-melodies or instrumentation changeups. This isn’t a remix of the original track: it’s a love letter to it. A fantastic job, and my top track for the album.

By Clark “Plazmataz” Powell

A symphonic treatment for Serenade from Volume 8, also written by Plazmataz. This one feels a little more like a tune-up: the brief, plucked strings and harp melody give it a new dimension. A soaring, piano-led except from Ruins ends the piece on a strong note.

Potential Homestuck ending #151: death of the reader.

By Clark “Plazmataz” Powell

A return to the energy of the album’s start: this composition is similar to Overture, if not quite a continuation. It features a fanfare version of Homestuck, and though it’s neat to hear the melody treated a little differently, I think it works a little better on the more low-key side.

RATING: 10 / 13 – Virtually Ensconced In The Fold Of My Personal Mythology

The best (yet woefully inadequate) short description I can come up for it is this: it’s a professional, symphonic ‘Pops’ treatment for a few well-chosen Homestuck hits. It’s a bit on the short side, and the 'bang for the buck’ is a little steep compared to some of the other Homestuck solo albums (though still quite competitive with your typical digital music release). 

My favorite part of this album is its subtlety, its nuance. Plazmataz has an entire symphony orchestra to work with. Yet you have moments like the intro to II - Sarabande, where the string section starts out almost sub-audibly, slowly rising for a full minute, right into the cello solo. His talent with the strings, in particular, is impressive.

Click here for individual song reviews for Symphony Impossible to Play.

Fanart source: Yoshi.

On to the next album: Medium, also by Clark “Plazmataz” Powell. Okay, fine, the guy in the picture’s more of a sooth than a medium, but whatever.

By Clark “Plazmataz” Powell

The strummed mandolin in the first half inspires visions of calm Mediterranean beaches. The second half skews a little more cheerful, shifting the scene to Caribbean shores with a bit of calypso rhythm. With a pretty strong honorable mention to Rain, this one’s my top track for the album.

By Clark “Plazmataz” Powell

With that rising, funky violin intro, it makes a perfect accompaniment for the discovery of a new world. The song rolls in waves. At times it’s improvisational and muted, only to be followed later by another crescendo.

… wow, I did really describe a violin-driven introduction as ‘funky’. I’ve got no better words, so there it is.

By Clark “Plazmataz” Powell

Image source: Homestuck.

The main rhythm sounds like it’s played by inevitable grinding gears, or maybe an elevator making its way down to an unfathomable horror. The violin melody brings with it a bit of an Eastern vibe.

By Clark “Plazmataz” Powell

Starts off with a light melody, yet surrounded by impending danger. The artificial sonic beat in the middle is cool, but my favorite part’s the outtro. With that unsettling, ultra-low synth growl behind the bouncy piano melody, the final two minutes is a dead ringer for a song that John could have played to wake up his denizen.

By Clark “Plazmataz” Powell

The thin, reedy soprano synth melody gives it a new-age feel, but sort of in distress, what with the malicious percussion in the back. I had to replay it a couple of times to catch the Westminster Chimes in the middle around 3:10: the melody is there, but the key’s so different from the rest of the song, it almost hides in plain sight.

RATING: 9 / 13 – reminds me mUch of home. so peacefUl

Well, Calliope might think that this album is peaceful, but that’s probably only because she grew up on the blasted ashes of Earth long after its demise.

Medium is the first solo album by Clark “Plazmataz” Powell. It’s primarily symphonic and atmospheric in tone. Many of the songs contrast a high, natural, treble melody against a deep, synthetic, industrial background. 

And there’s a lot of ambient effects and sound scattered throughout. It’s very professionally done: always to enhance a track, never to overwhelm it. The effects bounce between natural (rolling waves from Light, showers from Rain) and otherworldly (the quasi-industrial synth noises from Heat, the main melody from Clockwork).

Given the album’s title, it does very well to set a mood, to describe each of the particular settings it targets. And as a bit of background music, it excels.

Click here for individual song reviews for Medium.

Potential Homestuck ending #77: apocalypse Eggs.

‘Tis the season.

Homestuck for the Holidays up next, another unofficial album (though written almost exclusively by members of the music team). The entire album was created to help support the charity Child’s Play – please consider donating!

Turns out the Homestuck game was released 25 years ago.

By Thomas Ferkol

I like the intro, where it sounds as though half the melody is played by the not-quite random whim of the wind through a set of chimes. And the give-and-take between ‘God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen’ and Sburban Jungle fits well.

By Mark Hadley

A nice, solid, jazz quartet cover of the old standard. It’s my second favorite version of this particular song (a lot of terrorists have to die before my favorite version can play, though it’s somewhat similar in feel to this track).

By Toby “Radiation” Fox

I’m a fan of Carefree Victory, even though it’s on the short side and not much more than a fanfare. This track fleshes it out a little more and wraps a counter-melody around it, all for the better.

By Jeremy “Solatrus” Iamurri and Nick Smalley

A mashup of Carol of the Bells (the familiar arrangement is surprisingly modern, written in the first half of the 20th century by Mykola Leontovych) and Frost. With a little bit of shoehorning, the bells and the xylophone fit together well, and the simplicity of that horn solo in the middle fits both songs well.

By Robert J! Lake. Based on “Candles and Merry Gentlemen” by Tyler Dever

One of the more musically interesting tunes on the album. It’s a great version of Candles and Clockwork, and the vocals… well… it’s bizarre and ethereal. RJ has a unique sound that shows up in other songs, and I don’t know how else to describe it. Except that I like it.

By Alexander Rosetti

It’s weird, grating, and profane, but I laughed long and hard listening to an intoxicated Squiddle puke (very realistically, I might add) after too much egg nog. Which… somehow creates a Barkley-esque Nog Baby that absolves the Squiddles of all their nog-related sins. Absurd, surreal, and hilarious.

By Nick Smalley

image

Once I established my headcanon for the narrator as this guy (he built this town out of baling wire and blasting caps!), his ramblings became a little easier to bear. I see the concept, but the old man’s interludes make the album tough to deal with as a long-play.

By Nick Smalley

image

Nope, Wilbur Cobb didn’t really stick. I’ve already got a new old man headcanon for this dude. More topical.

RATING: 4 / 13 – ………………….. :|

shit. lets be santa.

This is Homestuck for the Holidays. It follows the typical formula for a Christmas album, mashing holiday standards up with material from the Homestuck catalog. It’s a fun, goofy album. I wouldn’t recommend it as ambiance for your formal Christmas event, though: it’s packed full of intoxicated, queasy Squiddles, Sweet Bro and Hella Jeff, and a crusty old man narrator.

Once again, as an unofficial album, it is available free of charge (there’s a download link on MediaFire here). Before the album was released for free, all proceeds were for a charity. Please consider donating to Child’s Play if you like the album: you can find them here at http://www.childsplaycharity.org/.

Click here for individual song reviews for Homestuck for the Holidays.

OK, time for the next review. There were four albums suggested: I’m going to review each of the four next. But which one first?

I’m going to cheat a little and not pick at random. Land of Fans and Music 3 was released about a week ago. Yes sir: brand new (unofficial) Homestuck music, for the first time in about nine months. And free Homestuck music to boot. So let’s dig into this pie while it’s still cooling on the windowsill. LOFAM 3, coming up next.