The one Homestuck mystery I want to know: What the heck was that alchemization of the hammer and Midnight Crew comic that John couldn't make at the start because it cost so much grist. (If I remember correctly that is.)

It was a Problem Sleuth game not a Midnight Crew comic and it could have been the Warhammer of Zillihoo since that debuted in Problem Sleuth and items can have more than one cost, but I suppose we’ll never know for sure