On the same vein of how people interpret classes, I personally think that the rage class is probably a good one to link with '(Hidden) Truth' and the blood aspect to be able to symbolize familial bonds, especially without how bloodlines are and such.
I can definitely see Blood tying in with Family Bonds for sure. As for Rage and Hidden Truths, well the Canon Aspect Description does say, and I quote:
They posses great contempt for lies or false ideas, including the stability that false ideas can impart. To them, the true is far more important than the good; they would tear down a system just to destabilize it if, by their reckoning, it is built on faulty premises.
So the concept of the “Hidden Truth” would fit that description. That may be a bit an overlap.
Would it be possible for a Godtier Witch of Heart to shapeshift, since Witch is an active change class and Heart is all about who you are at your core? It could sort of be like a defense mechanism, appearing as something you aren't to seem less vulnerable. I think of the way that Callie appeared to Jane(or roxy?) as a troll in their first "physical" meeting in a dream(i think?) as something comparable, but id like your opinion.
I’ve argued before about both Heirs and Witches of Heart being able to possibly Shapeshift, so yeah.
I feel like the offensive manifestation of the blood class would plasma and magma, since the first is a part of blood, and the second flows like it. I’m a phlebotomy student so I was thinking about this crap in class 😭
Huh, ‘Boiling Blood’ is definitely a thing and evocative of lava, and Karkat’s Land almost looks like it’s just full of lava even though it’s blood, so maybe.
It is not lava? The Land of Pulse and Haze isn't filled with a lava ocean?? *MIND BLOWN*
I’m pretty sure it’s blood! If I recall, Karkat says he hates it because it being filled with red blood feels like SBURB itself is mocking him for being a Mutant. Also, “PULSE” and Haze.
What classpects have you explicitly covered in depth ?
Fff- I don’t even know honestly, a lot of them though. Whenever someone asks me about a Class or Aspect I go through the Class’ tag to see if I’ve already covered it or not, so I wouldn’t be able to tell you off the top of my head.
Could a thief of mind literally take things out of there minds , in theory could they take an idea out of there head or the minds of other people ?
Huh. Arguably yes, since we’ve seen Roxy materializing things from Nothing, ‘taking an idea’ out of someone’s mind and materializing it could be a good take on that.
what god tier is Lapis Lazuli? and maybe Sardonyx if you can :3
Aaah, God Tier Analysis of other canons could be fun, but it’s been quite a long time since I watched SU and I’ve heard some interesting developments happened, so I’d rather leave my judgement about this topic until I get back into it.
I saw the post about thief of mind and wondered if dreams were included in the mind aspect like they could steal dreams and even objects from dreams say someone dreamt of a powerful item or a dead loved one a thief or rogue could basiclly bring those things to life
Dreams are technically something the Mind does, buuut Heart may be closer to Dreams actually, with a bigger focus on the Subconscious and knowing the Bubbles put Dreamers and Ghosts in the same place.
What if two siblings both played sburb in the same house? What would happen then?
I’ve argued before the game may split the house in two. There’s really no precedent for this, sadly, Caliborn and Calliope were going to do this exact thing until Caliborn decided to be a little shit.
It would seem Space, given Frog Breeding is done through ectobiology and needing to lock onto a specific- Actually maybe more Time and Space than just Space. With a possible, healthy dose of Life.
(On the topic of siblings in the same house playing sburb) maybe it would make two copies of the house?
The problem with this is that, for the Game to ‘Clone’ the two houses upon entry, you’d need to have both players enter at the exact same time, and the game to actually decide that’s something it deals with by cloning the house. I mean it’s not impossible, but Client-Server Chains and Entry Times are never easy when it comes to Homestuck, it’s already hard enough to get one Cruxite Artifact before the countdown runs out, let alone getting two and activating them simultaneously.
That’s another thing, what if the siblings’ Cruxite Artifact do NOT let them enter at the same time? Dave had an Egg, which forced him to just wait for it to hatch. John, Jade, Rose, all of them had to physically do something but Dave’s was basically just another Countdown. If one of the Siblings gets that but not the other, or if BOTH of them get that with two different times, synchronization ruined. There’s a lot of variables to account with. By general rule of thumb, given what we’ve seen, just one of the Siblings would play the Game, with the other being relegated to a non-Player, Supporting role.
Still though, if you DO manage to synch it up, the house-cloning is a fun idea.
is it not possible for one person to enter the medium with two sburb players in the same building,and then for the second player to enter the medium while in the medium?
Okay, NOW we’re getting Meta. It’s… Dubious to say, technically you’re already in the Medium so how everything would react to another Cruxite Artifact in there is hard to say.
also,could dreamselves not go through the process of entering the medium?
Technically it’s not about the version of the Player, rather than the Location that’s transported to the Medium. Jane, Dirk and Roxy were all Dreamselves when they went into SBURB, and they all went in through Jake’s Land- But they still had their own houses go into SBURB through Robot Shenanigans, so it’s not like the problem you’re posing at all.
What if it was two kids in the same apartment complex, you think? Or hivestem?
Now THIS one is actually answer-able! It’s likely limited to having the people in the higher floors enter First, but when Dave goes into SBURB only his floor and the Roof are warped there- Meaning SBURB can take the floors individually, at the very least, if there’s nothing else above them.
What dictates who should be on Derse and who should be on Prospit?
Not much, honestly. With the Extended Zodiac we have confirmation all Aspects can be both Derse and Prospit, and we have examples of different Dreaming Moons for different Classes. It’s not even by Active and Passive- Since Hussie explicitly mentioned how Derse Dreamers are influenced to be more Active, as seen with Rose, who was supposed to be a Passive Class, and Prospit influences them to be more Passive, which we can see in Jade, who’s supposed to be a Highly Active Class. Hell, we know thanks to Sollux that we don’t even need to have the same number of people in each Moon.
In the end, the ONLY thing that determines something, is Ectobiology. Only the characters that are paired to make their children/parents, and the children/parents themselves seem to follow the norm- The Strilondes to Derse, the Harleybertcrockglishes to Prospit…
Of course in a real Session, there would not be any Ectobiology, since that is reserved to the Session that spawned the Frog Temple- Making the Players to predestine them to play it so the Frog Temple can arrive in the first place. So in reality? Seems another matter of Personality, as seen on the Quiz.
I like to think the aspects are better at doing things than other aspects. Like Mind players can grasp concepts much faster than other players, even if it's not from their class, like time shenanigans. Or Blood players can make friends faster, even make friends from enemies. Void players would be excellent liars, and so on. It even works vice a versa. If you follow my logic, I would like to hear what you think. This is just a fun idea of mine, and doesn't account for what Class the person is
That seems very much how it is though- People of different Aspects are tied to said Aspects because of something in their Nature, so of course they’d be better at whatever that Aspect’s nature represents. So consider that ‘fun idea of yours’ pretty valid!
if you've watched Naruto, what god tier are the Team7 members?
Okay, remember that all of these are Headcanons and nothing set in stone, but I’ll give my reasoning as to why. Also it’s been a while since I’ve seen Naruto, specially the earlier parts of it, so a lot of this may be loose and kinda not true.
Naruto is a Heir of Doom. As a Magician, his Familiar is Kurama, which also happens to be something passed down to him by his Dad in his last moments- At least half of him. This destructive force inside of him Changes they way people interact with him, and he must learn to Control it to bring a Change to the pained Ninja World. If he allowed it to consume him, he’d become an Embodiment of Doom and wreck havoc upon the land. There’s also some inheritance themes with the whole Senju vs Uchiha feud. Being Changed by what happens around him, and bringing Change to the Ninja World, fits well for a Selfless, Change Class.
Sasuke is a Witch of Rage. To begin with, he actively seeks revenge against his brother- A relative acting as his Familiar, an external and great source of Rage for him, that Changes him and consumes him entirely, making him leave Konoha behind and seek to increase his power to get revenge. However when he gets to confront Itachi, not only is his point of view Changed and his Rage directed towards Konoha- And the System that made his brother do what he did (Thus, bringing Chaos and Anarchy), he also manages to wrestle the power from his Familiar- By awakening his Mangekyō Sharingan after he dies, and later physically having his eyes transplanted. This attitude of wanting to Change the World through Rage, and Changing through what Rage inspires in him, and the several different points his life takes a sharp turn from protagonism to antagonism and bath, fit the bill of someone Selfish and Change-related.
Sakura is a Maid of Blood. First of all, Healing Wounds would definitely be within the Maid of Blood’s power, which already ties in to the medical themes. The struggle with her worth as a kunoichi, later overcome as she becomes one of the most prodigious Medical Ninjas ever, as well as the struggles with her Bonds- Specially with Sasuke, which she centres on heavily and stubbornly chases up until the very end, reflect both traits of the Maid and the Aspect of Blood. Life could’ve been a candidate as well, specially her struggle with Agency, likening herself to Ino and then later on her obsession with Sasuke limiting her, as well as the Medical Theme, but I think Blood may fit her better than Life. Also, as good as she is healing others, her Stubbornness with Sasuke and temper in more comedic bits of the series seem to indicate a more Selfish, Active leaning.
Shit- Did you also want Sai and Kakashi? I posted it without thinking twice.
I had never even CONSIDERED how the Lands smell. haha asking for a friend
John’s being all Oily can’t be too pleasant either, and I don’t even want to THINK about the Land of Brains and Fire. Maybe with the Dead Themes and the Noble Gases of the Alphas there would be something bad there too but I don’t know how Noble Gases smell, if they smell at all, and all the Consorts seem so far dead there wouldn’t be smell of decomposition.
That being said? Imagine how GOOD Nepeta’s Land smells. Just sugar and tea.
Uuuh, Naruto up to the Ninja War Arc, then the Manga afterwards. Watamote, Boku no Hero Academia, Bleach, all of Jojo up until Part 7, a bit of SNK, D.Gray-Man, Lucky Star, One-Punch Man, Dragon Ball up to GT when I was suuuuuuper young… I’m sure I’ve watched more but they aren’t popping- Oh! Death Note of course. Gantz as well, Elfen Lied (Gotta read the Manga though since I know it continues)… And I’m sure a bunch more, but again, those are the ones I remember right now.
I’ve got a biiiiig ‘to-watch’ list too, Nichijou, FMA, Hellsing, Berserk… I remember watching Akira and Evangelion with my sister when I was younger but I’ve not retained ANY of the memories from those times.
could a Space player have Yaldaboath as a denizen instead? or is it only Echidna 100% of the time?
Yaldabaoth is a special Denizen, so he can replace others. Similarly, it’s implied that Abraxas is also a special Denizen in the same way, but not canonically confirmed.
LOHAC: smells like burning metal and rust, you can smell the stock market crashing LOWAS: smells like an oil spill with a minty breeze, a consort blows a bubble in your face LOLAR: smells like someone shoved a rainbow up your nostrils LOFAF: the cold is killing your nose but there is a hint of swampiness in the air, and whatever frozen frogs smell like LOLCAT: *throws 10 pounds of powdered sugar in your face along with 10 different cats*
Yes, good. Also remember LOFAF warms up later on so then it’d smell more swamp-like for sure. Hope you like Frog Smell.
welp Jake's planet is a death zone, have you heard what inhaling too much Xenon can do? at least Dirk's is manageable but I feel like the purple X going through Jake's planet has high amounts of Xenon which can lead to death actually
I have not really heard what excess of Xenon can do, but I do know Krypton in heavy amounts can suffocate due to lack of oxygen since it’s heavier.
Gamzee's planet smells like a carnival. Face paint, rubber balloons, popcorn, caramel and sweaty guys wearing clown costumes *cough Pennywise* speaking of, how would Gamzee react if he met Pennywise?
Depends, because if he’s Sober I think it’d be Pennywise who gets scared.
Sai is the Bard of Heart. He faithfully follows the cause he’s been assigned to, and allows his Feelings to be Destroyed while under the Anbu. It takes him a while to come out of his shell and start expressing himself more, however as he starts interacting with others and genuinely trying to understand others’ feelings and make his own known, he keeps accidentally messing up and ruining it. Then his more emotional moments coming thanks to Shin with the whole Resurrection Thing, he’s most definitely a Heart Player- I considered Space because of his art and the isolation aspect, but there’s too much of a focus on feelings. Bard, I’m not as sure, buuuuut it just kinda fit.
Kakashi is the Rogue of Space. This one was hard, but I knew he had to be one of the Steal Classes because of his Jutsu Copying, getting Obito’s Eye… He’s also lax when it comes to non-important matters and can kind of be seen being kinda abstracted and apathetic when it’s not a personal or really big thing, which fits the role of a Rogue. Even if he was more of a Thief in his early years, the whole thing with Rin and Obito made him very noticeably Rogueish, so let’s go with Rogue. As for Space, this one was a hard one too, there may be other Aspects that suit him, but, he copies Jutsus- Hand coordination and Chakra flow could definitely fall under the domain of Space, and then his ability to use the Kamui Black Hole thing really is Stealing Space into a pocket dimension is it not? Not to say, Space ties in with Isolation as well, and his lone nature.
Hi! Um I saw not too long ago that you had a test about what class you were? I'm not interested in the test but in the explanation of every class, I remember it was very well done but I only read mine... where could I find that?
It’s actually linked on my blog! If you check the sidebar thing about the Canon Quiz Test, it’ll link you not to the Quiz, but to the post I made about it, which in turn has a link to all 14 Class Explanations.
this is quite a few but what god tiers are All Might, Midoriya, Ochaco, Todoroki, Iida and Bakugo? and Tsuyu because everybody loves Tsu
sI may not go as in-depth with these to save some time, but leeeeet’s see…
All Might becomes a Beacon of Hope for everyone, to the point of putting his life at risk constantly even while his time limit becomes shorter and shorter, but he appears reliable and determined, so a Knight of Hope would fit nicely.
Midoriya inherits All Might’s power and this hope, and he puts himself on the line for others rather dramatically, so a Heir may work. Heir of Hope perhaps to go along All Might’s Knight of Hope-iness?
Uraraka may fit as the Rogue of Space- She’s a Passive Class for sure, with her being so nice and working so hard to try and get money for her family. Space could fit because wanting Money is a much more material and tangible reason than simply Heroism, and her powers fit the bill- Stealing someone’s Gravity and returning it. She could be some other Class though, perhaps a Sylph? Hmmm…
Todoroki may be the Prince of Blood. He was born as a result of his Dad just wanting to make a strong Quirk to beat All Might in some way- So his incredibly powerful Quirk comes as a result of Blood. And likewise, he hates his father and his means, so he seeks to Destroy this Familiar Bond, to the point of holding his potential back. A Bard may work as well but I feel like a Prince works nicely with both the high status and fighting against, not his own ego in this case, but his father’s, which he tries to impose on him, and also the big thing with him struggling with not letting his father get to him and some of his attitude has costed him when it comes to Hero stuff.
Bakugo may… Honestly be a Lord. He may be a Prince who does NOT struggle with his Ego and instead just absolutely revels on ‘how much better he is’, which leads to the struggle of finding his match and being bested from time to time outside of his raw power potential, and getting super conflicted. Actually? That may be better than a Lord. And if he’s a Prince, perhaps a Prince of Heart? He’s incredibly self-centred, completely ignores Midoriya’s adoration from him, destroying those feelings, and causes some big devastation by himself with his own powers, for himself.
Tsuyu is a Sylph of Space- The Canon Aspect Description fits her the most, but also, she’s a God Damn Frog of course she’s Space. I was considering her being Maid of Space is in, ‘she’s literally a frog’, but I think the Sylph suits her better personality-wise.
I have no idea if it’s Quotev that doesn’t work on mobile, or Tumblr that doesn’t show the sidebar link things on Mobile, but if it’s the latter, here it is!
Ok, but think of the psychological trauma all this would cause when your 13. Losing all your family members, everyone you've ever known except for a select few, having to kill hundreds if not thousands every week, and being completely isolated except for the concerts and talking online. Not to mention the fact that any point you can end up in a doomed timeline, or have your session be doomed from the very start. (1/2)
(2/2)Or all your friends get killed and you’re the only one left, and what if your god tier. You can’t suicide since it’s not Heroic or Just. You’re stuck, all alone for eternity
I still do think you can kind of choose to die if you’re a God Tier, otherwise honestly being a God Tier may not exactly be the best thing long-term, buuut yeah, see what I mean when I say SBURB is fucked up and we’d all probably die within a week of starting the game, if not before beginning it.
That being said, some people may not exactly mind isolating themselves from the outside world and their families, and if you make a big enough Session you may even drag in all of your friends. Better than being crushed by meteors tbqh.
Knowing Hope and Faith, sounds like they’d have a good understanding of Religion or at least their specific Religion, as well as seeing people’s convictions and the reasons they do stuff. They’d see Coherence where there only seems to be Chaos, and see what’s beyond the Storm so they can guide others and themselves through the toughest of times. A Mage of Hope sounds like they’d be stubborn about making things better, and would take matters into their own hands to bring forth the Hopeful future they’ve seen. Tying to Hope, they’re also very likely to have powerful Hopey Majyyks in general.
Ok thanks :) I got muse of time what God tier powers would I have
I once described the Muse of Time as a ‘Weaver of Fate’, technically speaking their impact on reality would be equal to that of Caliborn himself, but on the more Passive Spectrum, a sort of ‘Time Keeper’ ensuring the flow of time isn’t disrupted and things keep going as they should sounds about right.
I'm a teal blooded muse of time. Evaluate my personality please?
Oh yeah I’m prospit too
I don’t tend to do this too much I mean, if I were to say anything I would parrot what the Teal Caste + Prospit + Time Aspect + Muse Class Personality things would say, so it’d feel like just stating the obvious. But then also, more personal, and specially, personality ‘evaluations’ of people on a deeper level, specially not knowing them, feel a bit invasive and I don’t really like that too much.
Some fun Troll Names are Rocket Papaya and Andrew Hussie. Also, most characters in Undertale have 6-letter names that could be used for a Fantroll. Alphys, Undyne, Flowey, Asgore, Asriel, Toriel, Shyren, Muffet…
Can you please make puns with the all of Aspects?(and with the Classes if you can)
I’m sorry if you Mind that I’m going to ignore this ask, I just don’t have the Time.
Okay though, in all seriousness, you need some context to drop a Pun! Different Puns work in different Contexts, you can’t expect me to come up with 26 different Puns out of the blue without being in ~The Zone~! :p
I get it. You need context to shed some Light on the topic of puns. Don't want to make you Rage over the fact you can't come up with one when you're deVoid of any help. Plus you need Time to think of some good ones. I Hope you find a way to incorporate puns in the next ask though. That'd be Bloody awesome
Go home everybody, anon’s writing my jokes from now on. In all seriousness though, and while I don’t Mind these, I simply though these were not as punny as you might’ve wanted! If it’s just doing that? If you just let me catch my breath for a bit, of course I can come up with some fun ones. Otherwise, I couldn’t, for the Life of me, come up with other clever wordplay- Without context, this endeavor was Doomed from the beginning.
I poured my Heart into thoughs puns. It's been fun though. We've used almost all the Aspects except Space. So If you don't Mind I want you to make the last one
Sorry dude, I’m all outta puns actually, no good Space ones here.
if you're willing to classpect anime people... Allen, Lenalee, and Kanda from D Gray-man? and maybe the Earl if that's not too hard?
Oof these may be a bit more difficult, I can’t remember much about D.Gray-Man, I’m due for a re-read some time. Specially recently given there’s some really huge reveals about some of the characters later on that add a layer on top of what the beginning presents, maybe in a few months I can properly answer this one.
