Could a hope player revive someone out of the sheer belief that they can and will come back to life?
I imagine they may be able to but much like what I said a little bit ago about the Maid and Sylph of Life, there’ll likely be restrictions to not make death meaningless.
I would understand that the Courtyard Droll would have a "You're Welcome" card because he's a Dersite agent. But Gamzee? How did he even get a "You're Motherfucking Welcome" card? He isn't even Dersite and doesn't even form part of the Derse staffs!
He’s got one because fuck the rules. It’s a reference to the fact Hussie literally got a thing that punches his face and “You’re Welcome” on paper.
I'm pretty sure Galekh and Tagora would become Kismesis upon meeting each other because one has "not finished talking" and the other one makes one lose upon talking
Let them talk and get stuck into a Paradox.
Am I the only one who finds it nerdy and kinda silly that vriskas most powerful dice roll is to summon cosplay?
She’s nothing if not committed to her appreciation for Mindfang’s tales.
Do you think a troll could have an odd number of horns? Like 3 or 5?
In the Hiveswap Concept Art of the Subway Station, there was a Troll whose horns were on the middle of their head, making a mohawk-like shape. If that thing sticks in canon, there’s really no restrictions to how Horns may look.
Who would convey information in a more efficient way? A Knight of Light or a Seer of Light?
A Seer of Light may have more to say, but be more wordy and long winded. A Knight may be concise, but they may also not know as much and push themselves to get the information they need.

I’m calling it: a Japanese Jadeblood
Jade is possible, because of the horn shapes, although Jesus that’d be SO many Jades. I’m thinking maybe Cerulean for this one?
Japanese you say, hmm… A Topknot maybe? I always saw that as like. A mohawk with the right horn broken and a ribbon tied to it. But I could see Topknot too.
i was reading a bit a knight of mind and someone said their combat skills aren't the best but like. are you kidding me? a knight of mind could probably use electricity due to its connotations with mind, plan out highly strategic attacks, etc etc. i personally think they'd be great at combat
Knights of Mind could definitely be expert strategists. Battle Skill, however, is not quite tied to Class- I mean, look at Rose and Terezi, the Seers will fuck you up. It all depends on who the Knight is and how they’ve trained.
i've noticed the aspects are sort of split into... well, maybe not good and evil, but it seems like the aspects are "welcoming" or "intimidating," in a way. light is welcoming, void is intimidating. hope is welcoming, rage is intimidating. life and breath are welcoming, doom and blood are intimidating. heart/mind and space/time aren't as clear-cut, thought. heart could be seen as being more welcoming than mind based on name and space more than time based on the official whatpumpkin descriptions.
Aspect Talk may be coming soon enough, given we’re trying to see if the order of the Aspects in the Canon Wheel is arbitrary or if there’s something more to it. Either case, an association that seems to check out is a division of the wheel between more Conceptual and Idea-esque aspects, vs the ones regarding the physical Reality. Hope as Faith and Dreams, Rage as tearing said hopes and seeing the system behind. Breath as Detachment and goals, with Blood as attachment and actual interactions. Mind as the expression of yourself, with Heart as the true reality of who you are. Life and Doom. Time and space. Light and Void. It’s a good start to understand the Aspect Wheel I feel, but there’s more to dig into.
Honestly I don't even care that it'd be doomed, I wanna see the timeline where Equius got over himself and turned Gamzee into a fine purple mist
There was this great piece of fanart back in the day, about Equius standing up for himself and slamming Gamzee into a wall. Lemme see if I can find it.

aradia-chan:
homosexualpancakes:
sometimes i think about what it would have been like if equius had actually put up a real fight against gamzee
(you mean what would’ve happened if gamzee killed nepeta first)
What do you think Gamzee did to the black king of the trolls session?
I like the depiction in Rex Duodecim Angelus where he just fucking, brutally decapitates one of the heads and lets the blood rain over the Battlefield.
Is light and dark symbolism inverted for trolls?
Not necessarily always, but there are some notable examples. Vampires are creatures of darkness, dwellers of the night, but since Trolls are Nocturnal, Rainbowdrinkers can handle the Alternian Sun perfectly and glow in the dark (Because the Brooding caverns are dark af arguably).
Another speculation is that Witch is related to "breaking the rules" of their aspect. Feferi was able to establish an afterlife through dream bubbles, therefore breaking the rules of Life. Jade displays powers that completely go against the laws of physics.
I mean, God Tier is literal Godhood, I’m pretty sure every Aspect is shown violating some sort of rule of nature, from Resurrection to Creation out of Nothing, so ‘breaking the rules’ isn’t really exclusive to Witches.
What most disappoints me about Eridan is that if he had just gotten his shit together, instead of killing the angels, he could have commanded them, which sure as shit would come in handy against the black king and Jack Noir
The sad thing is that even being a douchebag and killing the Angels, I feel if the Trolls had won the game he would’ve still been a dick, but likely mellowed out or gotten help with his deeper issues. Instead being put in a hopeless situation only fed into his superiority genocidal complex. Oh whale.
... Spades Slick was definitely forgotten by the ending though. He gets decapitated and then is just .. gone. We don't even get to see his body disintegrate or something. No closure. ... Also whats up with Carapetions not getting into the dream bubbles?
Carapacians aren’t players. As fun as they are, they’re still NPCs and constant across Sessions. The presence of non-Players in the Bubbles is rather dubious- WV’s dream seems more like an actual dream than a memory- But we know from Jade’s first dream that normal dreams can still happen in the Bubbles and Vriska also appears in front of him, implying WV DID dream in the Bubbles? There’s also 3 Carapaces emulating the Problem Sleuth characters and the Lusii around, but whether they’re part of the memories or actually dreaming/souls is hard to say.
As for Spades Slick, I mean. He’s a Villain? Only driven to pretty much give the middle finger to Lord English and get payback for the bullshit back on Alternia. He tracked after him, got into a three-way fight, and ended up dying. There’s not much… Closure he could’ve had? Even the Jack that survived still took over the Felt and went to Earth to try and fuck shit up. Jack is just. Murderous and Dangerous. There’s no closure for the guy, only more stabbing and grudges.
When did Gamzee get god tier? Did we see it in comic?
His God Tier is fake.
How do you find out your class? Like if you're a Knight, heir, maid, ect. I know I'm a light Player but I have no idea what my class would be
Well, you need a good understanding of what the Classes mean for you, and introspection about who you are or would want to be. LUCKY FOR YOU if you’re indecisive I’ve got juuuuuust the thing! *Shameless self-promotion*
the best part of the gamzee decapitating one of the black kings heads is that gamzee wields BLUNT WEAPONS.
Exactly, although I like to think he straight-up disregarded his clubs and went in with his bare hands. Maybe teeth.
Could a maid of life theoretically use life powers to make something rot to the point of disintegrating? or would that just be a strictly thief of life power.
I’ve argued that Maids and Sylphs of life may be able to make Illnesses and grow cancers and mutations within others. Rotting seems more getting rid of Life rather than making it though, but who knows.
Does the staff grant the same transformation as the ring?
Seems to also make the King bigger, but other than that it’s the same additions.
Theoretically, considering Gam making contact with the BK isn't exactly shown, we can theorize that he either used a fraymotif or literally beat the BK hard enough that his head exploded or just turned to mush.
And that’s if we headcanon he tore his head off, for all we know he did something else and even more brutal.
So with the way doomed timelines work, do you think there is a timeline where rose did her land quest?
Not every possibility seems to exist in Paradox Space. I’d say Rose is so stubborn there’s not a single Timeline where she took her Quest.
Ehhh. There is also one timeline where Calliope won and like ... how low of a possibility was that?
Calliope predominated over Caliborn after simply not meeting anyone. Without her cheery demeanor and reduced to isolation, her will and determination proved to be overwhelming to the assholish brat that is Caliborn. It’s not that hard to imagine really.
can princes and bard of minds possibly prevent doomed timelines if they got help from a seer?
A Prince or Bard of Doom may be more fruitful.
It is rather hilarious that there are plenty of Eri ghosts that for some reason seem to be hanging aroung dead Sols... But then, it appears that some doomed timelines had trolls end up dealing with issues that were dealt with in alpha. Maybe if Eri dealt with his DRAMA QUEEN GENOCIDAL I AM SO DESPERATE FUCK YOU ALL shit they could have gotten along.
Are there? I can’t quite recall that. That being said, the Prince Outfit Eridan Ghost we see is hanging out with Feferi, implying God Tier Eridan did work out his issues.
i took your quiz and thought carefully about the questions and got a Prince but i feel like it didnt suit me well so i went to the next two but it's tied between a Page and a Witch. great.
:V Well just check which one suits you better.
Did you have a good time with your family
No.
Aw I'm sorry
Appreciated, but don’t be.
Do you think there are more than one successful timelines of the one we’ve seen? We know of only one but there must be more, right? Right?
Define ‘successful’.
I kept taking your quiz and trying to get what i thought i was by bs-ing answers and then getting page and pissing myself off cause like. Im Absolutely Not a page what the fuck??,? And then i took it and i didn't overthink what answers might mean or shit and i was honest and i got prince and like thats. Definitely me dbffhdbfchf
;3

Why is Dualscar’s horns white?
Huh, that’s a strange stylistic choice come to think of it. You know what? I’d bet the white lightning in the background is actually transparency and there was a white background underneath, and Hussie just forgot to fill the Horns.
I would have rather named the Prospitian-Breath Jade sign 'Virrus' instead of 'Virus' => VIRgo + tauRUS
But then they wouldn’t have been able to pull off a Virus sign! Because that Sign is most definitely made to look after a Virus.
Why do Equius, Gamzee and Feferi use a significantly darker colour for hemotyping?
Aesthetics, probably, it’s possible Hussie did it so their color would be easier to read on the light grey background of the MSPA website.
I’m just finding the Knights being passive thing, and I was wondering how a knight of heart would work? What you said really really resonates, and I think I may be a knight of heart instead of a rogue of heart!!! I know I’m passive, but I like knight. And I’ve never seen it as passive before!!! Sorry I’m rambling I just love your theory so much!!!!
It’s okay, don’t worry! I’ve talked about the Knight of Heart over here, although do remember this is, after all, just a theory! Knight could turn out to be the Active after all, and other pairs like Witch/Heir and Maid/Sylph may not be like that according to Hussie, but it’s what makes sense right now to me, so, have that in mind before getting too attached to a non-canon theory! :p
sorry for the weird question, what timezone do you live in? I'm having trouble sleeping, and in the magical dairy filled and waterlogged lands of Tillamook, it's a little after 4am
GMT+1 I believe? It’s 1:16 PM as I post this.
What kind of powers would a Heir of Hope have if they touched Caliborn's house Juju?
We have no idea if the Treasure gives Retcon Powers, if it was Heir of Breath Hypercharged Powers, or if it was because the people trapped in it were the 4 Betas and a combination of their powers, so it’s hard to tell.
What would be the classpects of Grimbark!Jade, Grimdark!Rose and Crockercorp!Jane?
Grimbark Jade’s still a Witch of Space I feel, she just gets meaner. Grimdark Rose definitely switches from Light to Void, and her behavior and powers lean towards Witchiness. Jane is being made into Condy’s Heiress, so she’s a Heir. I’ve seen her mentioned as a Heir of Doom quite a bit, but I couldn’t exactly tell you why 100% right now.
One thing I wonder about Hiveswap is whether or not Trizza knows that Condy is dead.
Condy isn’t dead during Hiveswap.
Roxy killed Condy tho?
Hiveswap’s events happen before Homestuck even begins, there’s several years and two iterations of an Universe to go through before she dies.
...wait what. Bu ... how
? Seriously though, how does Hiveswap make sense as anything other than a prequel?
Soldier Purrbeasts
But do the Alternian Warrior Cats have horns.
What if alternian cats are of the same species as Nepeta's lusus?
God I wish. The world needs more Pounce de Leon.
What is your OTP?
I have way too many ships, I kinda ship everything as long as Amporas aren’t included. Rosemary and Lime Cotton Candy are always good choices though.

Sooo, the Homestuck bot I follow posted this and I thought of you~
Link to post:
https://homestuckbot413.tumblr.com/post/170908807315/before-i-run-for-president-i-must-destroy-all
Why must I become the first thing you think about when you think about codpieces.
How do you think, is Seer of Void limited Voidy-based thinking in their abilities, or could they have some other powers related to Void? After all, they Know and Understand the Void, so maybe they could invite it to cover them, for example? ...or is the Seer just doomed to be a forever-support player (everyone around gets to do cool Voidy things, even the passive Rogues materialize things, and the Seer is just: "Oh hey I know how to use Void in thinking and planning")?
Have you seen the way Rose blasts Light Magic spells? Seers are not limited to Knowing abilities, it’d seem Classes can develop general Aspect Majyyk powers.
I think the scepter making the king bigger is a reference to how the real king can only move one field in real chess. 'Too big to move fast'. Like the Red Miles represent the queens infinite reach in all directions.
You know that’s a really good take on the Sceptre vs Ring duality I had never thought about, huh.
i started thinking about how there's no fire/ice aspect pair, but then i realized that dave and jade's planets are based around fire and ice respectively! so that may not be an aspect-wide thing, but it satisfies my fire/ice duality needs. just a thought i had.
Hah, Jade’s Land is pretty icy, even though her associated element is Earth. But yeah, Aspects don’t have clear cut elements like those- They’re all either split between Aspects or they sort of don’t appear at all.
cept for breath lmao. Because breath doesnt give a fuck
I mean, Breath uses Wind just like Light uses, well. Light. But neither of them are just Wind and Light. Technically speaking, ‘Space’ could control temperature (both Fire and Ice) and manipulate pretty much any element just because of the physical nature of space, but they’re not restricted just to those elements.
A bard of void that’s always fidgeting and putting themselves in the center of attention because the moment they do or become nothing things around them start getting destroyed.
That’s quite the literal take on ‘Destroying through Irrelevance’.