Okay but Knight of Blood engaging in a fight with an alien with just so happens to be a form of dating for said alien and winning by virtue of being accidentaly so good in alien dating so he "defeats" said alien whom no one was able to defeat. Is canon in homestuck. It happened.

Honestly we know so little about Charms that we don’t even know if the fight was actually part of the flirting, or if it was literally the tying up. Again, I don’t want to get into another day of Clover Bondage Analysis.