John <3 Roxy over Calliope <3 Roxy any day, I've always felt that John and Roxy have a depper connection with the fact that they're both from the same timeline and know all the bullshit that happened and I kinda hated it when I see all that scrapped away for Calliope and Roxy, like I LOVE Calliope don't get me wrong but I would've prefered if Roxy and John were flushed and Calliope had a platonic one with Roxy and Jane

I get where you’re coming from, and I think Roxygen is cute, and also I don’t mind the idea of a Poly Roxy just swinging between Callie, Jane and John, but. While it is true that John and Roxy do remember what happened in the GO! Timeline, they’ve literally only met three times in their entire lives up to that point. One when John told him about his life story and encouraged Roxy to make the Matriorb, one when he followed her after Rose had died, and then again in his Land, both before going and after returning to warp his entire Land into the new Session.

Meanwhile, Roxy and Calliope have arguably known each other since forever, with the Cherub trusting Roxy enough that she was the one person she told her name to when she feared she wasn’t going to come back. She loves Jane tons as well, enough to gift her with her Juju for her Birthday. She was the one who connected them all by giving Roxy and Dirk Trollian to contact with Jake and Jane, she makes drawings and stories about them and while she’s in another entire Universe, she’s the Fifth one of the group- Not like Karkat and the others, that were just the 12 assholes trolling them, until they got to really know each other, Calliope was a part of the Alpha Group.

You can like Roxygen, and I do like them as well, but you can’t objectively state that the bond John and Roxy share is deeper.