I agree that Homestuck is so great because there is so much to explore, but I can understand why some people want all the answers. While theorizing is fun, some people just want the answer and nothing but the answer, which is why I like the Extended Zodiac so much. It doesn’t spell out everything, but it confirms a lot. There still is that room for theories and speculation, especially if we aren’t getting official class descriptions.

I mean, I do understand that, and I respect that! Homestuck, in fact, has a lot of value just by what it is, the intrigue, the story, the characters, there’s a lot to love without going in deep. But I dislike when people explicitly say Homestuck is bad because it’s a complex story that makes you work for the answers.