What do you think about the theory where only one player survives and ends up become apart of the eldritch or just becomes ones because of how lonely/distraught they are?

I think there’s no basis to why it’d be like that since there’s really no reason why living flesh would be twisted into that of an Eldritch Monstrosity merely because of loneliness, because I still think suicide would count as Just push come to shove, because Doomed Timelines and Sessions tend to be slated for complete erasure and leaving just like, God Tiers alive in a failed Session seems kind of counterproductive, and because it doesn’t exactly align with the Horrorterrors’ goals and means of manipulation and forcing sacrifice in a Session- You’d think someone who’s gone through so much loss and death would be actively trying to prevent it, not causing it time and time again across infinite Sessions.

I’d see them becoming Horrorterror food a lot easier. Still an interesting headcanon in general though.

Also, think about Doomed Rose in the Davesprite Timeline, and Dirk in Game Over. They didn’t die. But they gave up. Giving up to complete and utter defeat and loneliness seems to count for the Timeline as the End as well.