Scratche's description of godtier death isnt as black and white as you make it seem. He said for a just death you would have to die by a hero, which isnt the case as Araneas death by the hands of the condesce is just.

Scratch also mentions those are extremely broad definitions and that it really varies from case to case, those are the two examples he gives- What I’m saying is that it fits the example he gave well enough. Wait, didn’t you just exemplify the Judgement thing in the previous ask by saying that Aranea isn’t heroic enough to have given Jade a Just Death and that’s why manipulation was involved? How is that different from Condy choking Aranea out? Or were you mentioning about the weird and broad thing? With how it’s more than what he just says. Ugh, sorry, my mind’s a mess.

I know what Scratch says, and I know that his two definitions aren’t the ONLY ways to die Heroic/Just deaths, and I know it’s a case by case basis. I was just mentioning the heavy similitude.