jonelias is incredibly funny and thematically compelling to me because of their character trajectories. like it starts out as twisted nbc hannibal season 1 psychological horror “you wouldn’t put a guy in situations” wherein elias runs his lab rat i mean jon through the archivist trauma punch card machine (“wind him up and watch him go”) and every day is tortured gothic horror protagonist day for him but he doesn’t quite get it yet. and then season 3 happens and jon’s a little further in the beholding’s grasp and he’s experiencing physiological changes which only elias understands and now we’re in vampirism metaphor territory, he turned you into a monster but he’s the only one who will offer you the absolution you seek! (“elias, am i still human?”) murderer mentor maker!!! and you hate him you HATE him but *will graham voice* where else would i go?
and then season 4 happens and audio recording by jonathan sims, the Archivist. point of no return. he’s extracting statements. he’s feeding. he’s unwittingly channelling elias (“you just need… a break.”) he’s scaring everyone at the institute, but doesn’t it feel a tiny bit good after having been powerless and at the mercy of all these other avatars for so long? and even then the only person in the whole world he can turn to for advise is elias because they’re alike. they’re mirrors. they were similar even before the beholding had its hold on jon, because to be avatars of the eye is to hold a shared, unabating curiosity for knowledge and both of them sought it out to protect themselves from the fears. why else would jon end up at the magnus institute if not for a guest for mr spider.
then there’s the panopticon reveal and turns out jon was trapped in a bluebeard narrative all along! but bluebeard’s just won. jon took the key and opened the door and found his secret but he’s not simply another victim, being bluebeard’s final wife means narratively distinguishing yourself from the ones that came before and he does. he’s the special one, he’s the archive. and jonah/elias says he did everything to free himself from pain and death forever, to free them both from it all forever. and he says “don’t worry, jon. you’ll get used to it here. in the world that we have made.”
and then. power dynamic reversal‼️now season 5 fumbled this badly but listen. the monster you created is coming down to hunt you for sport. the thing you created to escape annihilation is also the very thing that can end you at any given moment. “behold a god more powerful than i who comes to rule over me.” and then it’s “suffer for me, as i suffered for you.” and eventually they play out some equivalent of tackling each other off a cliff hannigram style. or dead ringers 1988. because they’re doubles they’re mirrors they’re shadow selves they’re the watcher and the archivist. conjoined. and one cannot exist without the other :)
![Screenshot of the magnus archives transcript, text as follows: [Door slams shut.] Elias: Thank you, John. Archivist: [Hissed] Shut up! [click]](../../../media/c8284b9d68f7988add6379987761dcb8cff62b3f.jpg)
