~~~spoilers for all of the magnus archives~~~
How popular is the take that Melanie and Georgie were actually in a Fearscape?
I feel like this must be a common take, but it’s hard to find just meta-theories for TMA, but just incase, here’s how I came to this conclusion.
Melanie’s Blindness
The are alot of blind people in the world. I know Melanie blinded herself under spooky™ circumstances, but nothing actively spooky was occurring other than being inside the magnus institute. Also as seen with Gertrude/Agnes, the flesh book and The Dark ritual, when you want to avoid an Entity, or several, you usually have to do some explicity spooky things.
Because of this I think Melanie is just normally blind, she herself seems to think her immunity is just because of her blindness too. Now I know Jonny hasn’t always been great on numbers and scales but there are ALOT of blind people, maybe the Eye only ignores people who are completely blind and not visually imperared but still, Jon should’ve been seeing dozens of blindspots just within the UK in the beginning of S5. So I think it’s safe to say Melanie’s blindness isn’t why she’s “immune”.
Observation Isn’t Overt
We know the Fearscapes aren’t constant hell, the camera is the most explicit, giving prolonged relief, but it was still a Fearscape, waiting for all that paranoia to ripen until it breaks and the fears decend. We see it in other Fearscapes like the falling titan or the medical centre where there might be hours or days of relative peace, but the fear is still there and the victims still exist to suffer. I think the camera can also explain how Melanie and Georgie weren’t visible to Jon even outside the tunnels, their fearscape relies on feeling “free” to some extent.
Furthermore, Jon still knew they where alive, so The Eye knew that aswell, it didn’t hunt them down to put them in a fearscape however, and that was because they already were, they were just “freeranged” and The Eye just wanted to monitor their vitals.
Lastly, Helen knew where they where. I know she was better at navigating the tunnels than Jon in S4, but we know in S5, all power comes and goes through The Eye, it’s how the smitings work, if she could find them so could The Eye.
Specificity
Basira inherited Daisy’s Fearscape, allowing her to travel freely, but she was still in a Fearscape, having to endure all the horrors Daisy commited and then having to carry on, viewing the Fearscapes without Jons protection. Knowing this helps plug another hole in our original theory, which is that this is quite a specific Fearscape. We know some are small, Martin’s only has a few dozen, but Basira’s is just hers. This I think sets the president that although Melanie’s and Georgie’s Fearscape is highly unique it’s still possible. (Maybe The Eye chooses unique ones for its Ex kids)
Georgie’s Fear
I know people will bring up Georgie and I’ll have to make a much longer post eventually but I think we’ve only ever been told how her power works from her POV, which I think is inaccurate. If we actually look at how she acts she does feel Fear, she just displays it as worry or anxietyusally for others. I think what Georgie actually is, is what everyone else is, an Avatar, specifically of the End. We only have one other End avatar, Oliver, but we see a numbing of emotions in him too. I think she’s unable to feel fear like others because she’s an End Avatar and that brings a dampening affect, for further proof see the book of the damned with Gerry and Eric, both who know it feels “bad” but still have their emotions dampened. Basically, Georgie is a misidentifyed Avatar and she can still feel Fear just not like she used to be able to.
What the Fear / FearScapeUK
Now what is their Fearscape? Firstly it doesn’t fit nicely into the 14 but that’s okay, we know in the apocalypse Smirks 14 is largely redundant. But their fear is simply their followers, both having this crushing fear of failing them, having to be the perfect leaders, and of losing them, which they always will. Just before S5 ends we see the Cycle about to restart.
Just Melanie and Georgie -> save a few -> save even more (“get greedy”) -> lose a big chunk -> lose them all -> alone again, Repeat.
They’d go through this anguish over and over until the End consumes all, it allows them freedom like Basira and Daisy but they still only exist to suffer like those in every other Fearscape.
TL;DR Georgie and Melanie weren’t lucky, they’re Fearscape is them watching those they’re supposed to protect being dragged of to torture whilst shouldering the guilt of being “spared”.