2025-05-20 5:50:33 ¶ ●

Saw a post by someone (they apparently blocked me cause I’m annoying and everyone hates me) that said something along the lines of agreeing that the way Jon was treated in season four was dehumanizing and cruel (correct) but went on a tangent about how if you think it was for no reason that you’re ignoring nuance and whatever and like…

Who was saying they didn’t have a reason for treating him that way?

I don’t think anyone was saying their actions made no sense??? Basira’s hypocrisy and Melanie’s using Jon as a scapegoat are the only points I’ve ever seen made regarding criticism towards them??? The point was never that they didn’t have their reasons and weren’t victims themselves??? Where is this information coming from? They are incredibly realistic characters with incredibly human reactions and I wouldn’t like them if I knew them because of those reasons. I don’t like hypocrisy. I don’t like when people foist blame onto other people.

I’ve never seen any real criticism against the girls include the idea that they were dog piling on him for no reason when there’s several cause that would be idiotic. You’re likely conflating the idea they weren’t justified with this idea that they had no reason. Cause they weren’t justified. Sorry.