it’s fascinating to me the way that different social media platforms result in different types of fandom behavior. while s5 of tma was airing, I spent a good amount of time on tma tiktok (I log back in about once every two months now, going back to in-person school after a year a half of lockdown seem to re-blanace my brain and made me once again not really enjoy the format) while still using tumblr as my main socmed, and while there was a lot of overlap in the fan culture, some things were notably different.
tumblr tma fans had near-encyclopedic knowledge of the source material, but it was kind of an ongoing joke for tiktok tma fans that everyone binged the whole show in a week-long fugue state and lost memory of about 35% of it. tumblr has virtually no character limit and allows posts to be passed around by users indefinitely, which lends itself to fairly in-depth meta analysis being made and shared until most any fan could say “the time and space discrepancies at hill top road? psh yeah, I know all about them, I’ve read seven scrupulously cited posts that lay out all the details.” for the entire time that s5 was airing, tiktok videos could still only be a minute long, and I know from a lot of personal effort that there’s only so much you can fit into a one minute script that you also have to memorize and record (and cc manually with tiktok text stickers, as they didn’t add the caption feature until april 2021) if you want the process to take less than four hours of your one mortal human life. and then you only see the video if your following or fyp algorithm shows it to you. there were a few tma meta-ish videos that got popular because other people would make their own videos referencing them and tag the account so their followers could see what they were talking about, but it’s much harder to circulate content you like there. several times I saw people post videos saying “I got into cosplay to film some [agnes or annabelle or gerry or another secondary character] and I just realized I have no idea what their deal actually is 💀”.
a thing that tiktok tma fandom was definitely better at than tumblr tma fandom was accurately remembering certain pieces of characterization and the flow of certain scenes. I’ve seen a bunch of posts on here where someone is trying to argue a point with excerpts from the text (“x character is nicer than you all give them credit for” “x character is so mean to y character in this scene” “z theory can’t be true because y character said a line that disproves it”) where the argument only holds up because the poster has gotten these excerpts from a transcript dive and hasn’t listened to the episodes they’re from recently, because while the text alone can be construed to mean one thing, the way it’s delivered on-podcast clearly intends another. tiktok, being an audio and video based medium, allows audio clips to be shared around a lot, and cosplayers would often all make videos acting along to the same show clips of juicy interpersonal drama, and so tiktok fans, though they may have had less overall memory of what characters said, always had a better grasp on how they said it. an average tiktok tma fan might not have remembered melanie’s subplot about war ghosts, but they would know the nuances of how the way she talks to jon changes between mag 28 and mag 155.