I bring you new lonelyeyes headcannon about how Peter and Elias got together!

Jonah was boasting to Simon about his seduction skills and how they over the years only got better. And so Simon made a bet with him about whether will be Jonah able to seduce person of his chosing. And Simon of course chose young Peter Lukas.

And so Jonah tries. To Simon’s amusement he is not very successful no matter how hard he tries. Not even the tricks that worked on Mordechai works on Peter.

So when Peter all annoyed asks him what’s his deal and why cannot he leave him finally alone frustrated Jonah admits the bet with Simon.

However Peter is at the moment annoyed by Simon who keeps beating him in cards and so he makes a deal with Jonah and pretends to be seduced by him.

Based on how was Simon’s and Jonah’s bet formulated it could even lead to fake marriage!

Anyway unfortunately they catch feeling along the way!

Oh wait this is fake dating AU… hah I did not realize till now… Anyway I will probably add this on list of my fanfic plans…