so a while back i made a post about what my blorbos’ playstyles would be like in botc/social deduction games in general, and at the time i didn’t include tma because they have so much highly specific trauma and dangerous eldritch appetites that this would be terrible for, but i just can’t stop thinking about the very silly scenario where the tma characters play botc together. it would go so badly.
the banned character list includes fortune teller, spy, snake charmer, oracle, evil twin, vigormortis, no dashii, pacifist, cannibal, cult leader, fisherman, pixie, golem, plague doctor, organ grinder, and ojo, because elias keeps cheating. ojo and oracle somehow keep ending up in the bag anyway.
daisy gets way too into hunting down the demon. Guns Will Be Drawn.
jon and tim handle this game Extremely Predictably. i just know s1 tim would adore botc but s3 tim is having an awful time. oh great yeah one of our friends is a shape shifting demon lying to our faces? perfect. jon is on the verge of a panic attack but instead of breaking down he’s just interrogating everyone very aggressively. hey, at least everyone believes he’s on the good team.
basira solves the game right away and spends the rest of the game trying to convince everyone else. only georgie believes her.
martin is very good at being evil in these kinds of games (and also benefits from people not expecting him to be good at it), so when he pulls the demon he could demolish good, but, uh, he’s honestly not sure jon could handle that right now so he gets caught on purpose without letting anyone else realize he threw.
elias insisted peter would attend and he did not in fact show. luckily no one believed he would come so it’s not really a problem. (“you called it a ’social deduction’ game, elias, it’s in the name! no i’m not coming–”)
…annabelle’s the storyteller? i mean. she obviously would if she was there. i feel like sasha gives me st vibes as well but i might just be projecting again.
multiple games are ruined because jon accidentally compels the demon to tell him their role. one of those was not fully an accident.
simon is having a grand old time but he really doesn’t give a shit about winning/the game which is less of a problem when he’s good but very much a problem for his teammates when he’s evil.
melanie draws the psychopath “by chance” several times and enjoys it way too much. daisy handles an outed evil player whom town can’t easily execute exactly as poorly as you’d expect. i cannot emphasize enough how unlikely it is that canon team archives could play this game without at least one person getting hurt, killed, or giving in to the dark powers completely.
helen is eating it all up. literally. (elias is still pissed that the spy got banned.) she still never outright lies, which unfortunately for everyone else but fortunately for her (and simon, who thinks its hilarious) means she can’t tell outright truths when she’s good either or it’ll look suspicious when she’s evil. no one is ever fully certain what she is or what she’s doing. pure chaos and we love her for it. (we being me; team archives does not in fact love her for it.)
elias is still cheating, but when they threaten to fill the room with eyeless dolls he decides to quit while he’s (not) ahead and just watch from his office like an eldritch twitch chat.